Walk-In Tub vs. Walk-In Shower: Which is Best For You?

Jan 23, 2024

These 6 questions will help you put the walk-in tub vs walk-in shower debate to rest

You’re ready to create a safer and more accessible bathroom, but the first decision you have to make can be the most difficult: Walk-in tub vs. walk-in shower? Both types of bathing spaces offer great benefits for aging-in-place, universal design, and bathroom remodels for seniors. But there some factors that make walk-in tubs the best option for some, while a tub-to-shower conversion might be right for others.

To help narrow down the best type of shower space for you or your loved ones, we’ve developed an easy quiz with just six questions. Click through the quiz to see what type of bathing option is best for your situation, and scroll down to learn why each question is important in your walk-in tub vs. walk-in shower considerations.

Convert garden tub to shower columbus bath design

Take Our Quiz!

6 Important Walk-in Tub vs Walk-In shower considerations

Whether you choose a walk-in tub vs a walk-in shower comes down to who uses the bathing space, how they prefer to shower, and a few other special situations. 

1. Age. Statistically, older adults are more likely to experience a fall at home. The National Safety Council puts this number at 25% for Americans over age 65. Keep that in mind for walk-in tubs, which have built-in safety seating, or when adding a seated option like a bench seat to a walk-in shower.

2. Frequency of Bathtub Use. People who take baths frequently may not like the idea of giving up their bathtub, while others simply don’t like to sit in a bathtub. Still others enjoy the a bath, but don’t use their tubs very often. This decision can help guide the walk-in tub vs walk-in shower conversation. 

3. Health Concerns. Walk-in tubs offer hydrotherapy benefits, such as the ability to soak sore muscles and improve circulation. Some of these benefits can also be gained from a walk-in shower, but the soaking element of a walk-in tub is especially helpful.

4. Mobility Needs. Regardless of age, anyone in your household who uses a mobility aid may need special bathing considerations. This could come in the form of a low or no-threshold shower base, a tub-to-shower transfer seat, more stability with grab bars

5. Personal Preferences. In our quiz, this question revisits the bathtub frequency consideration, outlining all the possible bath and shower configurations for your consideration.

6. Assistance & Caregiving. Depending on age, ability, and other needs, some people may require assistance when bathing. Walk-in tubs and walk-in showers each have pros and cons for caregivers who provide help with getting in and out of the bathing area, and with actual bathing needs.   

Walk in Tubs and showers are both great options. We can Help you choose the right one for you!

Whether you’ve taken the quiz and made your choice or still need help choosing between a walk-in tub and walk-in shower, the Improveit team is ready to help. 

Click here to schedule an appointment with a trained design consultant, or call us at 855-637-2999 with any questions!

universal design bathrooms for walk in tubs and showers quiz
The Richards new shower features bathroom trends 2023 and walk in tubs and showers quiz
Troy, OH
Double-Hung Window Replacement
Carole VanOsdol
Pataskala, OH
Kitchen Refacing & Countertop Replacement
Sue & Terry Ogle
Lancaster, OH
Outdated Bathroom Update
Susan & Don Amrine
Columbus, OH
Walk-In Tub Installation
Loretta Seipel
Cincinnati, OH
Tub-Shower Combo
Dylan Luman
Beavercreek, OH
Steve Hildenbrandt
Columbus, OH
Tub-Shower Replacement
Brittany & Randy Van Sickle
Hanover, OH
Window Replacement
Teddy & Maxine Jump
Frankfort, KY
Window Replacement
Sarah Puttoff
Springfield, OH
Window Replacement
Sheila Albin
Newark, OH
Tub-to-shower conversion
Jack & Maribeth Stover
Circleville, OH
Accessible Shower
Krista Bower
Fairfield, OH
Hopper Window Replacement
Issac & Isabella Garcia
Englewood, OH
Window Replacement
Joyce Stewart
New Paris, OH
Tub-Shower Replacement
John Newman
Bellefontaine, OH
Tub-Shower Combo
Kay Marquis
Mt. Washington, KY
Tub to Shower Conversion
Tom & Georgia Breeding
Mt. Washington, KY
Window Replacement
Tom & Georgia Breeding
Springfield, OH
Tub to Shower Conversion
Jim & Khristeene Richards
Waldo, OH
Garden Tub Removal
Ted & Wanda Davis
Hamilton, OH
Garden Tub Removal
Gibbs Family
Westerville, OH
Tub to Shower Conversion
Carol & Robert Young
Grove City, OH
Tub to Shower Conversion
Michael & Sharen Huffman
Louisville, KY
Window Replacement
Sarah Whittle
Tipp City, OH
Window Replacement
Tabitha Bundenthal
Cincinnati, OH
Window Replacement
Cheryl Raine
Hebron, KY
Window Replacement
Karolyn & Richard Malsi
Cincinnati, OH
Window Replacement
Deedra Rainey
Etna, OH
Bathroom Remodel
Gary & Melody McCardle
Etna, OH
Window Replacement
Gary & Melody McCardle
Marion, OH
Bathroom Remodel
Josephine & Charles Wiseman
Pickerington, OH
Window Replacement
Alan Lancaster
Pickerington, OH
Bathroom Remodel
Alan Lancaster
Upper Arlington, OH
Shower Remodel
Laura & Blake Williams
Marysville, OH
Bathroom Remodel
Amy & Alan Henderson
Columbus, OH
Window Replacement
Bonnie Morgan
Louisville, KY
Window Replacement
Sharon McDermott
Galloway, OH
Window Replacement
Paul Gray
Marysville, OH
Window Replacement
Linda Fyffe
Reynoldsburg, OH
Window Replacement
Keith & Carol Crabtree
Delaware, OH
Bathroom Remodel
Robert & Eileen Richardson
Columbus, OH
Bathroom Replacement
Joanne & Charles Duncan
Whitehall, OH
Bathroom Replacement
Jennifer Baldwin & Mike Ray
Check out some of our
favorite projects!

See What Our Customers Have to Say

BBB
Rating
A+
Google
Rating
4.7
Facebook
Rating
4.7
Facebook
Rating
A
Guild Quality
Rating
4.8
Improveit Home Remodeling Improveit Home Remodeling
Enter For a Chance to Win a
$45,000
Home Makeover
Improveit Home Remodeling
4580 Bridgeway Avenue, Ste B, Columbus, OH 43219
Contact Us
8930 Global Way, West Chester, OH 45069
Contact Us
110 Citizens Blvd, Simpsonville, KY 40067
Contact Us
7200 Poe Ave Suite 102, Dayton, OH 45414
Contact Us
110 Citizens Blvd, Simpsonville, KY 40067
Contact Us
Bathrooms Windows Kitchens